QC Opinion for ‘Clean Air in London’ on Air Quality Law (including Heathrow)

Simon Birkett, Founder and Director of Clean Air in London, said:

“The law about air pollution is not being properly applied.  So ‘Clean Air in London’ (CAL) asked Harrison Grant, its environmental solicitors, to obtain advice from Queen’s Counsel on the approach which planning authorities across the UK should take to Air Quality Law (see notes).

“In particular CAL wanted to clarify the extent to which planning decisions should take into account breaches, or potential breaches, of air pollution limits.

“CAL received that advice today from Robert McCracken QC and is publishing it immediately.  The opinion has relevance: for everyone interested in planning including the Government and Mayor of London; and to planning-related decisions about infrastructure, possible airport expansion or east London river crossings.

“In seeking the advice, CAL has sought to clarify key legal protections that exist for the general public in relation to ambient or outdoor air pollution.  CAL’s aim is not to discourage sustainable development but rather to ensure that tough decisions to reduce air pollution and protect public health are taken by the Government, the Mayor and other planning authorities.  In CAL’s view, such action must include the urgent banning of diesel exhaust from the most polluted places – just as the UK banned coal burning, so successfully, nearly 60 years ago.

“CAL intends to issue a more detailed statement in due course.”

ENDS

Government announcement about airport expansion on 10 December 2015

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/government-confirms-support-for-airport-expansion-in-the-south-east

Notes

1. Robert Mc Cracken QC Opinion for ‘Clean Air in London’ (signed 6 October 2015 with note)

CAL 322 Robert McCracken QC opinion for CAL_Air Quality Directive and Planning_Signed 061015

CAL 322 Stephen Tromans QC legal_opinion on LP Parking 280915

CAL 322 GLA document and Stephen Tromans QC legal_opinion on LP Parking 221015

2. Directive 2008/50/EC on ambient air quality and cleaner air for Europe (the Air Quality Directive 2008/50/EC).  The Air Quality Directive 2008/50/EC applies across Europe to protect public health and has been transposed into UK law.  It provides important protections beyond those already in the Clean Air Act 1956 and the Environment Act 1995.

http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:32008L0050&from=en

3.  Related attachments

 air-quality-planning-guidance v1.1

CAL 304 Letter of clarification from the Commission 190214_Redacted

CAL 304 Letter to Greenwich re Enderby Wharf 130515_Scanned

APPEAL DECISION Hassocks

Planning appeal_Richborough Estates_100615

uksc-2012-0179-judgment

CAL 297 Defra guidance for EA on LVs etc_February 2013 (2)

CAL 322 Letter to DG ENV_Letter from Michele Dix TfL – 020512

CAL 322 EPUK aq_guidance 2010

CAL 318 Submission to EAC re LHR 020915

Heathrow consultation – 4 March 2019

CAL 374 Response to LHR consultation 250219 V2

The attached the four scenarios that would affect Westminster most.

A1 is Expanded Heathrow (3 runways) – Arrivals (3,000 feet to 4,000 feet) – Design envelope A1.  Up to 32 flights per hour above 65 decibels.

Heathrow scenario 1_A1

A2 is Expanded Heathrow (3 runways) – Arrivals (2,300 feet to 3,000 feet) – Design envelope A2.  Up to 47 flights per hours above 65 decibels.

Heathrow scenario 2_A2

D2 is Expanded Heathrow (3 runways) – Departures (3,000 feet to 12,000 feet) – Design envelope D2.  Up to 17 flights per hour above 65 decibels.

Heathrow scenario 3_D2

I1 is Independent Parallel Approach (2 runways) (3,000 feet to 4,000 feet) – Design envelope I1. Up to 25 flights per hours from 6am above 60 decibels then up to 3 flights per hour above 65 decibels.

Heathrow scenario 4_I1

Related articles

‘CAL’ calls for investigation into Government’s failure to publish a ‘Pollution Alert’

‘CAL’ calls for investigation into Government’s failure to publish a ‘Pollution Alert’

‘Clean Air in London’ is calling for an investigation into the Government’s failure to publish a ‘Pollution Alert’ warning the public about HIGH ozone air pollution in southern England on Wednesday 26…

London must be ‘diesel-free’ by 2030

London must be ‘diesel-free’ by 2030

London must be ‘diesel-free’ to comply with new WHO air quality guidelines. Average concentrations of nitrogen dioxide (“NO2”), a toxic gas, monitored in Outer London were significantly lower in the first six…

‘Clean Air Scorecard’ 2024

‘Clean Air Scorecard’ 2024

‘Clean Air’ Scorecard 2024 Clean Air in London’s (“CAL’s”) final scorecard for the Mayoral and London Assembly elections on 2 May 2024 has been published here: CAL-529-Ranking-of-Mayoral-manifestos-2024_Version-1.0_020324 CAL has previously scored the…

ULEZ expansion is an important step on the path to phasing out diesel in London

ULEZ expansion is an important step on the path to phasing out diesel in London

ULEZ expansion is an important step on the path to phasing out diesel in London ULEZ expansion targets the final group of diesel vehicles in the last part of London to achieve…