Skip to content

MENU

Quick guide to air pollution
MENUMENU
  • Public
    • Understanding
      • Annual Pollution Maps
      • Breathe London Blueprint
      • Clean Air in Cities App
      • Defra modelling 2015
      • Defra annual reports
      • How polluted is my road?
      • LAEI 2013
      • London Air
      • 187 focus areas
      • Mayor's useful links
      • 50 polluted roads
      • NO2 diffusion tubes
      • Oxford Street NO2
      • Schools near roads
      • Roadside modelling
      • South East schools
      • What kills Londoners?
    • Action
      • 10 steps
      • Airgonomics podcast
      • Chief Airgonomics Officer
      • Cycle Streets routes
      • EN 13779 hospitals
      • EN 13779 London 2014
      • Face masks
      • Get our mobile app
      • LAQM
      • Legal guide
      • London Plan
      • Mayoral questions
      • Mode choice
      • Putney Society
      • Sunday Times Clean Air Campaign
      • TfL cycling routes
      • Under the Dome (Part 7 from 9.36 mins)
      • Using FOIA/EIR
      • Using social media
    • Smog
      • airTEXT
      • Breathe London - Sloane Street
      • Copernicus
      • Defra hourly bulletins
      • Defra UK-Air
      • EEA Air Quality Index
      • Episodes
      • Health advice
      • Hourly bulletins
      • Jetstream
      • London Air
      • Mayor's school report 2016
      • MetClim
      • Met Office guide
      • Modelling
      • Plume London
      • RBKC monitors
      • SAS selection deaths 2013
      • Smog list on Twitter
      • 24 hour forecast
      • 84 hour pressure
      • 5 day weather
      • 10 day weather
      • 2 week weather
      • World cities AQI
  • Media
    • Media
      • News alerts
      • News
      • Statements
    • Links
      • Davey Cartoons
      • Flickr
      • Facebook
      • LinkedIn
      • Twitter
      • Vimeo
      • You Tube
  • Policy
    • Policy
      • Our Manifesto 2016
      • Clean Air Act
      • Health
      • Indoor
      • Legal
      • Olympics
      • Solutions
      • Sources
  • Resources
    • Guides
      • Guides
      • Guide to the 'Clean Air in Cities' app
      • Pollution Check
      • Pollution Suppressor
      • Smog
    • Resources
      • Davey Cartoons
      • App
      • Ella's Law
      • Indoor air
      • One Atmosphere (Vimeo)
      • One Atmosphere (YouTube)
      • Photos
      • Presentations
      • Videos
    • Links - Ella's Law
      • Clean Air (Human Rights) Bill
      • Ella’s Law
      • ellaslaw.uk
      • Ella Roberta Family Foundation
      • Inquest
      • EU lessons
      • Library briefing
      • New WHO AQGs
      • Petition
      • Supporters
      • The CCC's advice
    • Links - Health
      • Aphekom
      • Cognitive effects on children
      • COMEAP
      • IARC: Diesel
      • IARC: Outdoor/PM
      • JAMA
      • NO2 health study
      • NO2 meta-analysis
      • Public Health Indicators
      • PHI COMEAP advice
      • PHI Defra data
      • PHI PHE advice
      • RCP report 2016
      • Wellcome Witness - Air Pollution Research in Britain 1955 - 2000
      • WHO guidelines 2005
      • WHO AQG 2008
      • WHO AQG update 2017
      • WHO air pollution
      • WHO indoor guidelines
      • WHO HRAPIE
      • WHO outcomes
      • WHO publications
      • WHO REVIHAAP
    • Links - Legal
      • Air Quality Directive
      • AQSR 2010
      • CJEU judgment 2021
      • ClientEarth case
      • DG Environment
      • EU infringement cases
      • ECJ Judgement
      • EU Clean Air
      • EU Clean Air | Twitter
      • EU DGR findings
      • EU Environment Impact Assessments
      • EU financial sanctions
      • EU Fitness Check
      • EU infraction
      • EU infringement UK
      • EU legal processes
      • EU lessons
      • EU media releases
      • EU NECD emissions
      • EU NECD 2016/2284/EU
      • EU NECD revision
      • EU new AQ Directive 2022
      • EU reporting
      • EU TTIP
      • M4 bus lane
      • Planning resources
      • UK National Emissions Ceilings Regulations 2018
    • Links - Policy
      • Breathe Life 2030
      • Chief Airgonomics Officer website
      • CityAir
      • Defra media releases
      • DPF removal
      • Diesel emission standards
      • Diesel exhaust 2007
      • Diesel exhaust 2011
      • Diesel - history
      • Emissions Analytics EQUA Index
      • Engineering Cleaner Air
      • European Environment Agency
      • Fumifugium
      • GEO6
      • GEO7
      • Gothenburg 2020
      • Healthy Air Campaign 'asks'
      • Late lessons 1
      • Late lessons 2
      • LEZs in Europe
      • PX 2015
      • PX 2016
      • SDG scorecards
      • Shipping
      • 10 climate measures
      • What will climate change look like in your area?
      • WHO SLCP measures
  • About
  • Contact
  • Register

Mayor must stop financially incentivising carcinogenic diesel exhaust

Posted by Simon Birkett on 1 February 2013
News, Solutions, Sources
Download pdf

Consultation on proposed changes to the Congestion Charging Scheme (Greener Vehicle Discount)

Dear Sir or Madam

I am writing on behalf of Clean Air in London (CAL) with comments on this consultation, which closes on the 8 February.

CAL is a company limited by guarantee which campaigns to achieve urgently and sustainably full compliance with World Health Organisation (WHO) guidelines for air quality throughout London (and elsewhere).  CAL is independent of any government funding, has cross-party support and a large number of supporters, both individuals in London and organisations.  CAL provides a channel for both public concern and expert opinion on air pollution.

Please note that this response is focused on proposed changes to the Greener Vehicle Discount (GVD).  CAL currently has no views on other proposed changes to the Congestion Charging Scheme.

CAL understands that the primary aim of the Congestion Charge is to reduce congestion, and its associated negative impacts, inside the charging area.  An important secondary objective is to reduce the environmental impacts of road vehicles in central London.  Road vehicles emit both carbon dioxide (CO2) and air pollutants (such as oxides of nitrogen (NOx) and particulate matter) from their exhaust pipes.  Emissions of CO2 from vehicles in the charging area are relatively insignificant on UK and Greater London scales, however emissions of air pollutants from the same vehicles are of critical importance for air quality in central London.  The prime environmental impact of road vehicles in the charging area is therefore air quality, with CO2 emissions being an important, but secondary, consideration.  You will be aware that the WHO has classified diesel exhaust as carcinogenic for humans.

The original, technology based, Congestion Charge discounts were successful in accelerating the uptake of new, low emission vehicle technologies such as petrol/electric hybrids.  The GVD introduced in January 2011 has been much less successful in this respect. As the consultation document points out, ‘since …   January 2011, the number of qualifying car models has tripled and many of these cars no longer have the lowest emissions on the market’.  The majority of qualifying vehicles are relatively small, cheap diesel cars i.e. vehicles that do not need incentives to encourage their uptake.

CAL believes that the suggested 75 g/km CO2 limit for the new GVD will suffer similar problems, namely that small, cheap diesel vehicles that meet this criteria will soon flood the market.  At the time of writing diesel cars emitting 84 g/km were widely available (e.g. Hyundai i20, 1.1 CRDi Blue).  Figures from the Society of Motor Manufactures and Traders showed average emissions from the ‘mini’  car segment  fell  by  5.6%  during  2011  (the  latest  year  for  which  figures  are  available), continuing the trend of declining CO2 emissions from all sectors of the vehicle market.  The ability of the motor industry to quickly drive down CO2 emissions from conventional diesel vehicles should not be underestimated.

The current GVD also includes air quality criteria: qualifying vehicles need to meet the Euro 5 standard for pollutant emissions.  Euro 5 sets separate standards for diesel and petrol vehicles, with diesel vehicles ‘allowed’ to emit considerably more air pollution than equivalent petrol vehicles. Evidence also now suggests that Euro 5 diesel vehicles emit considerably more NOx in urban driving conditions than previously thought, and also that more of this NOx is emitted as ‘primary’ nitrogen dioxide (NO2).  Providing small Euro 5 diesel vehicles with free access to the congestion charging area has therefore been a huge backwards step for air quality.

It is essential that the new GVD criteria do not simply replicate the failures of the previous system. They must prioritise air quality by setting an effective air quality standard and a stretching upper limit for CO2 emissions.   Emerging low and zero emissions vehicle technologies (such as electric and natural gas vehicles) will struggle to gain market share if conventional, cheaper diesel vehicles enjoy exactly the same tax and charges advantages.  This need for support is underlined by the slow sales of battery electric vehicles in the UK – in 2012 only 1,262 were sold.

CAL  recommends  that  the  GVD  should  be  reformed  to  set  strict  and  explicit  new  limits  for greenhouse gas AND air pollution emissions at the earliest administratively practicable date e.g. 1 July 2013.  We suggest that a two stage approach should be used to provide clarity to owners of low emission vehicles:

•           From 1 July 2013 the GVD should be restricted to vehicles that have maximum CO2 emissions of 75g/km and are proven to beat the Euro 6 emissions standard in real world urban driving conditions.   In practice this is likely to be electric, plug-in hybrid and biomethane vehicles

 •           From 31 December 2014 the GVD should be restricted to vehicles that have zero emissions at the point of use e.g. battery electric and fuel cell vehicles

The Euro 6 standard for cars and light vans will come into force on the 1 September 2014 for new types of vehicles, and from 1 January 2015 for the sale of all vehicles.  Many manufactures are now ‘pre-complying’ with new model releases to avoid having to make modifications to vehicles part way through model cycles.

Due to the high NOx emission from Euro 5 diesel vehicles, the proposed continuation period for vehicles that meet the current Greener Vehicle Discount criteria is also too long.   These vehicles should have to pay the Congestion Charge from no later than 31 March 2014, instead of the proposed date of 29 June 2015.

Yours faithfully

Simon Birkett

Founder and Director

Clean Air in London

All news articles

Share this post

Share this article on Facebook Share this article on Twitter Share this article on LinkedIn
Tweets by CleanAirLondon

Calendar

  1. Anniversary (2013): Tragic death of Ella Roberta Adoo Kissi-Debrah

    February 15, 2023

  2. Anniversary (1956): Atmospheric Pollution – Medical Research

    March 5, 2023

  3. Anniversary (1954): City of London (Various Powers) Bill

    March 10, 2023

View all events

Categories

  • Apps5
  • Clean Air Act8
  • COP261
  • Great Smog1
  • Guides17
  • Health96
  • Hot topics18
  • Indoor20
  • Legal125
  • News264
  • Olympics23
  • Presentations17
  • Solutions91
  • Sources49
Clean Air in London is a company limited by guarantee, registered in England and Wales, with company number 7413769 and registered office Thames House, Mere Park, Dedmere Road, Marlow, Buckinghamshire, SL7 1PB
Privacy policy Terms of use

Favourites

  • ClientEarth
  • Healthy Air Campaign
  • Keep the city out
  • London Air Quality Network
  • Take a Breath
© 2023 Clean Air in London Registered company number 7413769
Allow us to send you notifications about news posts?
× No Thanks
This site uses cookies: Find out more.