Skip to content

MENU

Quick guide to air pollution
MENUMENU
  • Public
    • Understanding
      • Annual Pollution Maps
      • Breathe London Blueprint
      • Clean Air in Cities App
      • Defra modelling 2015
      • Defra annual reports
      • How polluted is my road?
      • LAEI 2013
      • London Air
      • 187 focus areas
      • Mayor's useful links
      • 50 polluted roads
      • NO2 diffusion tubes
      • Oxford Street NO2
      • Schools near roads
      • Roadside modelling
      • South East schools
      • What kills Londoners?
    • Action
      • 10 steps
      • Airgonomics podcast
      • Chief Airgonomics Officer
      • Cycle Streets routes
      • EN 13779 hospitals
      • EN 13779 London 2014
      • Face masks
      • Get our mobile app
      • LAQM
      • Legal guide
      • London Plan
      • Mayoral questions
      • Mode choice
      • Putney Society
      • Sunday Times Clean Air Campaign
      • TfL cycling routes
      • Under the Dome (Part 7 from 9.36 mins)
      • Using FOIA/EIR
      • Using social media
    • Smog
      • airTEXT
      • Breathe London - Sloane Street
      • Copernicus
      • Defra hourly bulletins
      • Defra UK-Air
      • EEA Air Quality Index
      • Episodes
      • Health advice
      • Hourly bulletins
      • Jetstream
      • London Air
      • Mayor's school report 2016
      • MetClim
      • Met Office guide
      • Modelling
      • Plume London
      • RBKC monitors
      • SAS selection deaths 2013
      • Smog list on Twitter
      • 24 hour forecast
      • 84 hour pressure
      • 5 day weather
      • 10 day weather
      • 2 week weather
      • World cities AQI
  • Media
    • Media
      • News alerts
      • News
      • Statements
    • Links
      • Davey Cartoons
      • Flickr
      • Facebook
      • LinkedIn
      • Twitter
      • Vimeo
      • You Tube
  • Policy
    • Policy
      • Our Manifesto 2016
      • Clean Air Act
      • Health
      • Indoor
      • Legal
      • Olympics
      • Solutions
      • Sources
  • Resources
    • Guides
      • Guides
      • Guide to the 'Clean Air in Cities' app
      • Pollution Check
      • Pollution Suppressor
      • Smog
    • Resources
      • Davey Cartoons
      • App
      • Ella's Law
      • Indoor air
      • One Atmosphere (Vimeo)
      • One Atmosphere (YouTube)
      • Photos
      • Presentations
      • Videos
    • Links - Ella's Law
      • Clean Air (Human Rights) Bill
      • Ella’s Law
      • ellaslaw.uk
      • Ella Roberta Family Foundation
      • Inquest
      • EU lessons
      • Library briefing
      • New WHO AQGs
      • Petition
      • Supporters
      • The CCC's advice
    • Links - Health
      • Aphekom
      • Cognitive effects on children
      • COMEAP
      • IARC: Diesel
      • IARC: Outdoor/PM
      • JAMA
      • NO2 health study
      • NO2 meta-analysis
      • Public Health Indicators
      • PHI COMEAP advice
      • PHI Defra data
      • PHI PHE advice
      • RCP report 2016
      • Wellcome Witness - Air Pollution Research in Britain 1955 - 2000
      • WHO guidelines 2005
      • WHO AQG 2008
      • WHO AQG update 2017
      • WHO air pollution
      • WHO indoor guidelines
      • WHO HRAPIE
      • WHO outcomes
      • WHO publications
      • WHO REVIHAAP
    • Links - Legal
      • Air Quality Directive
      • AQSR 2010
      • CJEU judgment 2021
      • ClientEarth case
      • DG Environment
      • EU infringement cases
      • ECJ Judgement
      • EU Clean Air
      • EU Clean Air | Twitter
      • EU DGR findings
      • EU Environment Impact Assessments
      • EU financial sanctions
      • EU Fitness Check
      • EU infraction
      • EU infringement UK
      • EU legal processes
      • EU lessons
      • EU media releases
      • EU NECD emissions
      • EU NECD 2016/2284/EU
      • EU NECD revision
      • EU new AQ Directive 2022
      • EU reporting
      • EU TTIP
      • M4 bus lane
      • Planning resources
      • UK National Emissions Ceilings Regulations 2018
    • Links - Policy
      • Breathe Life 2030
      • Chief Airgonomics Officer website
      • CityAir
      • Defra media releases
      • DPF removal
      • Diesel emission standards
      • Diesel exhaust 2007
      • Diesel exhaust 2011
      • Diesel - history
      • Emissions Analytics EQUA Index
      • Engineering Cleaner Air
      • European Environment Agency
      • Fumifugium
      • GEO6
      • GEO7
      • Gothenburg 2020
      • Healthy Air Campaign 'asks'
      • Late lessons 1
      • Late lessons 2
      • LEZs in Europe
      • PX 2015
      • PX 2016
      • SDG scorecards
      • Shipping
      • 10 climate measures
      • What will climate change look like in your area?
      • WHO SLCP measures
  • About
  • Contact
  • Register

Nitrogen dioxide and racial and social inequalities

Posted by Simon Birkett on 11 October 2011
Health, Legal, News
Download pdf

Secretary of State
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
Area 5F Ergon House
Horseferry Road
London
SW1P 2AL

11 October 2011

Dear Secretary of State

Nitrogen dioxide and racial and social inequalities

I am writing to express my grave concerns regarding omissions in the recent consultation conducted by Defra on Plans and Programmes for compliance nationally with legal standards for nitrogen dioxide (NO2) that have since been submitted to the European Commission.

The consultation process closed on 5 August 2011.  As part of the consultation documents the public were not given any information as to the likely adverse impacts on diverse ethnic communities from continuing high levels of NO2.  I wrote to Defra asking whether any race equality information existed and was informed by them on 31 August 2011 that you had not carried out any race equality impact assessment for populations affected by NO2.

Between 13 and 16 September 2011 I attended a conference in Barcelona organised by the International Society for Environmental Epidemiology (ISEE) where I saw presented research conducted by Imperial College and funded by the Small Area Health Statistics Unit (SAHSU) (which is part of the MRC-HPA Centre for Environment and Health which receives Government funding) into the social and racial inequalities associated with NO2.  It was titled ‘Associations between small area levels of air pollution and socio-economic characteristics in the Netherlands and England’.  I was alarmed to learn that racial and social inequalities for NO2  were up to double those for PM10.  The research  has  not  yet been  published  so  I  do  not  have  a  copy  of  it  and  my  recollections  are approximate.

Defra’s  Racial  Equality  Impact  Assessment  (England)  into  PM10   dated  August  2009  (attached) indicates that Asian or Asian-British-Bangladeshis in urban areas were exposed to 24% more PM10 than White-British in 2005 and Black or Black-British Africans in urban areas suffered a staggering 28% greater exposure to PM10 when compared with White-British.  On average across all ethnic minority populations the statistics showed ethnic minorities suffering 17% greater exposure to PM10 in urban areas when compared with White-British populations within England.   As you know, premature mortality is correlated with higher exposure rates.

The picture now emerging for ethnic communities faced with continued high levels of NO2 as a result of Government plans to extend its time for compliance with EU laws is much more serious.  If I have remembered them correctly, the SAHSU statistics suggest the continuing breach of EU targets would play a significant part in perpetuating exposures up to 50% greater for some ethnic minorities relative to White-British.  You will appreciate that NO2  concentrations are strongly correlated with those of other toxic gases from combustion e.g. road traffic.

As I understand it, the Secretary of State has a general duty under section 149 of the Equality Act 2010 to provide and promote race equality and in particular to have ‘due regard’ to the need to eliminate unlawful discrimination, harassment and victimisation and advance equality of opportunity between different groups.

In having due regard you must show you have taken into account, in particular, the need to remove or minimise disadvantages of a protected group, such as ethnic populations and take steps to meet the needs of such groups.

I have been unable to find any evidence that you have had any regard to the serious health impacts for ethnic  populations  of  current  NO2   levels  in  proportion  to  those  suffered  by  White-British  or considered conducting any kind of meaningful assessment of the need to eliminate those levels for the purposes of race equality and the advancement of equality within the UK.

There is no doubt in my mind that many from the ethnic community would consider a doubling in exposure rates as hugely racially discriminatory and be wanting to know what immediate steps were proposed by the Secretary of State to mitigate and prevent such harmful impacts to their health.

In view of the fact that Defra possess (or could be in possession) of data and information in relation to ethnic populations directly and indirectly affected by increased levels of NO2  I consider it expedient for the Secretary of State to immediately carry out a further consultation on the following:

a)      whether the current air quality Plans and Programmes amount to unlawful discrimination;

b)      whether the current air quality Plans and Programmes are likely to have an adverse impact on the promotion of equality of opportunity; and

c)      whether there is likely to be an impact on the promotion of good relations and, if so, the nature, extent and duration of the impact.

Please explain what Defra meant when it said on 31 August 2011 ‘we have no documentation with respect to…your request”.  Does that mean Defra held information in one or more other forms and if so what is it?

I would ask the Secretary of State to provide justification for why the current: Plans and Programmes; and policy to request an extension of time for some zones from the European Commission regarding UK commitments to meeting its EU obligations towards NO2 level are not racially discriminatory.

Yours sincerely

 

 

Simon Birkett
Founder and Director
Clean Air in London

 

Cc:

Commissioner Janez Potočnik
Joan Walley MP
Environmental Audit Committee

All news articles

Share this post

Share this article on Facebook Share this article on Twitter Share this article on LinkedIn
Tweets by CleanAirLondon

Calendar

  1. Anniversary (1955): Coke Prices (Increase)

    January 31, 2023

  2. Anniversary (2013): Tragic death of Ella Roberta Adoo Kissi-Debrah

    February 15, 2023

  3. Anniversary (1956): Atmospheric Pollution – Medical Research

    March 5, 2023

View all events

Categories

  • Apps5
  • Clean Air Act8
  • COP261
  • Great Smog1
  • Guides17
  • Health96
  • Hot topics18
  • Indoor20
  • Legal125
  • News264
  • Olympics23
  • Presentations17
  • Solutions91
  • Sources49
Clean Air in London is a company limited by guarantee, registered in England and Wales, with company number 7413769 and registered office Thames House, Mere Park, Dedmere Road, Marlow, Buckinghamshire, SL7 1PB
Privacy policy Terms of use

Favourites

  • ClientEarth
  • Healthy Air Campaign
  • Keep the city out
  • London Air Quality Network
  • Take a Breath
© 2023 Clean Air in London Registered company number 7413769
Allow us to send you notifications about news posts?
× No Thanks
This site uses cookies: Find out more.